Freedom and Structure: A Balancing Act



I've been listening to a book on tape called "Aristotle's Children: How Christians, Muslims, and Jews Rediscovered Ancient Wisdom and Illuminated the Dark Ages" by Richard E. Rubenstein. This book is NOT Christian but it is an extremely interesting book of history which involves the Christian faith. One of the chapters contrasts the organization of the Muslims in medieval Spain with the Christians in Europe. The Muslims basically had religious teachers but not central headquarters. In essence, they had no denomination, Islam was a way of life. The Muslim scholars who studied Aristotle did not entirely connect with Muslim orthodoxy, nor was there mechanism for checking academic freedom they were working within against an official position.




The reconciliation of Aristotle with Muslim thought was attempted by individuals and eventually fizzled. But they did pass on their attempts to Christian scholars in Spain, who took the study of Aristotle to a whole new level. However, they accomplished this by within the medieval Catholic church, not along side her. Rubenstein says that the Christian scholars had "the advantage of backwardness". If I understand it correctly, this means that the lack of sophistication means that they could afford inconstancy for a while and as the scholars continued to study. But a separate advantage that the medieval Christian scholars had over the Muslim scholars is that they had a structure to work within the church. In contrast the Muslim scholars were Muslims of secular professions, like court lawyer, who came in conflict with the clerics. By working within the confines of the church organizational structure, the Christian scholars had less freedom and more oversight from the church. As I understand it, I'm not claim to be an expert here, is that the oversight gave them a rigor in their study which forced them to work harder at reconciling the Aristotelian philosophy with their Christian faith. The Muslim scholars in contrast were allowed a lot of freedom and after they had accomplished the bulk of their work, it was marginalized by the community which it attempted to serve.



Disclaimer

(Mind you, I'm not attempting to criticize Islam, I'm addressing the social phenomena. In other ages, Islam spread quickly and powerfully because they were masters of reconciling their faith to the diverse cultures to which they were spreading. As a Christian, I see reconciling worldveiws with faith as a essential component of spreading the faith.)

Some Reflections Inspired By This Book

The Open Source programming community has rigor imposed by the computer itself. Programming requires a program to work. In contrast, Open Source Theology can actually be done without such rigor; sloppy theological coding so to speak.

In our modern over idealization of academic freedom, we could actually be hurting ourselves by not requiring a rigor in our study that checks our worst tendencies in study. Engineering has a hazing process called calculus to bring rigor to its study. In the past, mastery of Latin and Greek were components which brought rigor to the humanities. In our modern climate we actually have to freedom to be silly. (I don't mean funny either.)

We often seek to influence change by creating new organizations, change may be more effective by coming within and already existing organizations. When reconcile two opposing views, its harder actually reconcile them as an outsider, the tendency is to create a competing idea, an antithesis.



A Bible Text About Reconciling Old Ideas With New

14 Then the disciples of John came to him, saying, “Why do we and the Pharisees fast, [3] but your disciples do not fast?” 15 And Jesus said to them, “Can the wedding guests mourn as long as the bridegroom is with them? The days will come when the bridegroom is taken away from them, and then they will fast. 16 No one puts a piece of unshrunk cloth on an old garment, for the patch tears away from the garment, and a worse tear is made. 17 Neither is new wine put into old wineskins. If it is, the skins burst and the wine is spilled and the skins are destroyed. But new wine is put into fresh wineskins, and so both are preserved.” Matthew 9:14-17 (ESV)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

In The Hours

Image
In The Hours Words by Helen L. Parmelee Music by Kevin Twit http://www.igracemusic.com/hymnbook/lead/inthehours.pdf This song by Indelible Grace is one that really moves me. I think it moves me because it reminds me of my own story. The words remind me of God's work in my life through the blessing of suffering. A lot of my best days walking with my Lord has actually been days of suffering. Verse one reminds me of growing up when I felt rejected by others but God was my song. 1. In the hours of pain and sorrow, When the world brings no relief When the eye is dim and heavy, And the heart oppressed with grief While blessings flee, Savior Lord we trust in Thee! While blessings flee, Savior Lord we trust in Thee! Verse two talks about my drifting from the Lord when I was caught up in pride and the sin of self-sufficiency. 2. When the snares of death surround us, Pride, ambition, love of ease Mammon with her false allurements, Words that flatter, smiles that please Then ere we yield, S
Read more

Was the New Testament Letters Only Written to Male Brothers?

  Question:   Was the Bible written to men only and not to women?   Some teach that the New Testament letters address brothers exclusively.      Executive Summary Answer:   Women and men share in the blessings of the gospel, Scripture was written for both women and men. So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them. (Gen. 1:27 ESV) Answer:   The Bible recognizes differences between genders but also recognizes the commonality between male and female genders.   The book of Proverbs is written to sons to gain wisdom.   “Hear, my son, your father's instruction, and forsake not your mother's teaching, for they are a graceful garland for your head and pendants for your neck.”   (Prov. 1:8-9 ESV) The book of Proverbs was written in order to teach young men wisdom.   Even so, often it is the female gender that teaches wisdom.   Early in the book, the male gender, a son, is to embrace the teaching from a member of the
Read more

Bridging the Chasm

My good friend the Jollyblogger has been writing on Bridging the Chasm , meaning the church communicating with the secular world. In the early 80's YWAM put out a pamphlet on missions prayer. One of the things they encouraged Christians to pray for was different areas of influence: * Government * Business * Media/Journalism * The Arts * Education * Entertainment (I'm not sure that is the complete list.) As I prayed for these areas of influence, I found that Christians really wrote about a couple of these in the early 80's; Government and Business. For government you had movements like the Moral Majority and Focus on the Family writing actually about a very narrow aspect of government; moral issues. Yes, I'm grouping all Focus on the Family's issues in the area of moral issues. The government is so much more than moral issues. The business issues were mostly addressed by Bill Gothard, Larry Burkett and later Ron Blue. I'm not sure how ade
Read more